Bedford Avenue is now open for curbside pick ups - learn more!
Take a virtual tour of our studio!
Our Wedding Annex is now open by appointment ♥ 
Learn more about our new global shipping!
Search
My Cart
Contact Us
Account
Personalized Jewelry
Personalized Jewelry

31 Items

per page
Sort By
  1. Tiniest Key Charm, Yellow Gold
    Make it Personal
    Tiniest Key Charm, Yellow Gold
    Catbird Jewelry
    $88.00
  2. Full Heart, Silver
    New
    Make it Personal
    Full Heart, Silver
    Catbird Jewelry
    Catbird Exclusive
    from
    $40.00
  3. Full Heart, Rose Gold
    New
    Make it Personal
    Full Heart, Rose Gold
    Catbird Jewelry
    Catbird Exclusive
    from
    $140.00
  4. Full Heart, Yellow Gold
    New
    Make it Personal
    Full Heart, Yellow Gold
    Catbird Jewelry
    Catbird Exclusive
    from
    $140.00
  5. Baby Cygnet Ring, Yellow Gold
    Make it Personal
    Baby Cygnet Ring, Yellow Gold
    Catbird Jewelry
    $128.00
  6. Grand Cygnet Ring, Yellow Gold
    Make it Personal
    Grand Cygnet Ring, Yellow Gold
    Catbird Jewelry
    $218.00
  7. Baby Cygnet Ring, Silver
    Make it Personal
    Baby Cygnet Ring, Silver
    Catbird Jewelry
    $54.00
  8. Grand Cygnet Ring, Silver
    Make it Personal
    Grand Cygnet Ring, Silver
    Catbird Jewelry
    $72.00
  9. Isabel's Treasure Signet Ring
    Make it Personal
    Isabel's Treasure Signet Ring
    Elisa Solomon
    Catbird Exclusive
    $1,464.00
  10. The Smallest Love Letter Charm
    Make it Personal
    The Smallest Love Letter Charm
    Catbird Jewelry
    Catbird Exclusive
    $138.00
  11. Dollhouse Heart Locket, Gold
    Make it Personal
    Dollhouse Heart Locket, Gold
    Catbird Jewelry
    $168.00
  12. Dollhouse Heart Locket, Silver
    Make it Personal
    Dollhouse Heart Locket, Silver
    Catbird Jewelry
    $58.00
  13. Dollhouse Locket, Silver
    Make it Personal
    Dollhouse Locket, Silver
    Catbird Jewelry
    $58.00
  14. Dollhouse Locket, Yellow Gold
    Make it Personal
    Dollhouse Locket, Yellow Gold
    Catbird Jewelry
    $168.00
  15. Letter Cutie Charm
    Make it Personal
    Letter Cutie Charm
    Bittersweets NY
    $186.00
  16. Written in the Stars Band, Narrow
    Make it Personal
    Written in the Stars Band, Narrow
    Sofia Zakia
    $1,650.00
  17. Small Heirloom Signet Ring
    Make it Personal
    Small Heirloom Signet Ring
    Leo Black
    $398.00
  18. Large Heirloom Signet Ring
    Make it Personal
    Large Heirloom Signet Ring
    Leo Black
    $680.00
  19. Beyond is All Abyss Necklace
    Make it Personal
    Beyond is All Abyss Necklace
    Bittersweets NY
    $550.00
  20. Zodiac Ring
    Make it Personal
    Zodiac Ring
    Talon
    $124.00
  21. Gold Name Necklace
    Make it Personal
    Gold Name Necklace
    Marian Maurer
    $570.00
  22. Viola's Treasure Signet Ring
    Make it Personal
    Viola's Treasure Signet Ring
    Elisa Solomon
    Catbird Exclusive
    $1,393.00
  23. Tomboy Ring, Yellow Gold
    Make it Personal
    Tomboy Ring, Yellow Gold
    Catbird Jewelry
    Catbird Exclusive
    $198.00
  24. Tomboy First Knuckle Ring, Yellow Gold
    Make it Personal
    Tomboy First Knuckle Ring, Yellow Gold
    Catbird Jewelry
    Catbird Exclusive
    $148.00
  25. Tomboy Ring, Silver
    Make it Personal
    Tomboy Ring, Silver
    Catbird Jewelry
    Catbird Exclusive
    $68.00
  26. Tomboy First Knuckle Ring, Silver
    Make it Personal
    Tomboy First Knuckle Ring, Silver
    Catbird Jewelry
    Catbird Exclusive
    $48.00
  27. Tomboy Ring, Rose Gold
    Make it Personal
    Tomboy Ring, Rose Gold
    Catbird Jewelry
    Catbird Exclusive
    $198.00
  28. Tomboy First Knuckle Ring, Rose Gold
    Make it Personal
    Tomboy First Knuckle Ring, Rose Gold
    Catbird Jewelry
    Catbird Exclusive
    $148.00
  29. Number Rings
    Make it Personal
    Number Rings
    Bittersweets NY
    $175.00
  30. Famous Letter Ring
    Make it Personal
    Famous Letter Ring
    Bittersweets NY
    $144.00
  31. L'il ID Bracelet, silver
    Make it Personal
    L'il ID Bracelet, silver
    Bittersweets NY
    $160.00

31 Items

per page
Sort By

Personalized Jewelry

Make it your own. Tell a story.
Metal
Stone
Designer